The rumors held true and North Dakota native Andrina Brogden has officially made it to the top 15 girls of American Idol. 19-year-old Brogden and 21-year-old Leah Guerrero were called in front of the judges together for the verdict. Guerrero performed a nearly flawless rendition of Etta James' 'I'd Rather Go Blind', but in the end, Brogden advanced to the live rounds with her fiery performance of Ellie Goulding's 'Burn'.

Andrina tweeted how difficult the situation was:


So far, the following contestants are moving on to the semifinal round:


  1. Andrina Brogden
  2. Jillian Jensen
  3. Bria Anai Johnson
  4. Jessica Meuse
  5. M.K. Nobillette
  6. Kristen O'Connor
  7. Emily Piriz
  8. Malaya Watson


  1. Malcolm Allen
  2. Jordan Brisbane
  3. Spencer Lloyd
  4. George Lovett
  5. Alex Preston
  6. Dexter Roberts
  7. Maurice Townsend
  8. Sam Woolf
  9. Emmanual Zidor

Relive Andrina's captivating performance and the judge's gut-wrenching final decision:

Do you think the judges made the right decision between Andrina and Leah?